Bangladesh
Water Issues
Emaduddin
Ahmad |
Introduction
In the last few
decades, water
management practices
in Bangladesh
were mainly concerned
with finding ways
to develop water
resources in response
to an increasing
demand in the
agricultural sector.
This practice
brought the country
close to food
self-sufficiency
in the 1990s.
However, focus
on water development
is now missing
in the country's
policies. Many
areas in Bangladesh
are now confronted
with deteriorating
quantity and quality
of existing water
resources and
economic development
is leading to
a negative impact
on the life supporting
ecosystem. It
is envisaged that
rapid growth of
population, economic
activities and
climate change
will further complicate
the water development
issues in the
years to come.
Water
Sector Development
in Bangladesh
-
Till
the 1950s –
Flood Management
with small dykes
under individual
control, irrigation
from river water
using manual
or semi-mechanical
lift.
- Water
Sector Master
Plan of 1964 --
Concepts of major
flood control,
drainage and irrigation
projects. This
implementation
continued until
1971. The objective
was safe paddy
cultivation.
-
IBRD
Review 1972
-- Concept of
small scale
project with
emphasis on
irrigation using
ground water.
Large coverage
could be achieved
by private sector
initiative.
Food grain self
sufficiency
was achieved
but with adverse
impacts such
as lowering
of ground water
and arsenic
pollution.
-
1983-1989
and 1990-1995
-- Master Plan
Organisation
(MPO)
and Surface
Water Simulation
Modelling Programme
(SWSMP).
Flood Action
Plan (FAP)
considered 26
components after
the floods of
1987 and 1988,
initially on
the flood, and
finally on round-the-year
water management.
Regional study
on environmental
impacts was
introduced.
However, due
to a lack of
quality control
in managing
the studies
at one times
and results
of pilot studies
not in, the
FAP could not
provide definite
and useful output.
Simultaneously
Flood Forecasting
was introduced
using mathematical
model to support
flood management.
Major and important
secondary rivers
were covered.
Due to limited
upstream information,
lead time was
inadequate.
-
A
new National
Water Management
Plan has been
initiated in
2004. The plan
is guided by
the National
Water Policy
introduce in
early 1999.
-
2004
-- The National
Water Management
Plan (NWMP)
was approved
by the Government
of Bangladesh.
Achievements
and impacts
So
far 60 per cent
of Bangladesh has
been brought under
flood control and
drainage. Many of
the projects are
not well maintained
due to lack of funds.
No tax rule exists
to recover the cost.
Adverse impact of
water logging, disallowing
available necessary
flooding, closing
navigational routes
and an overall shortage
of fresh water fish
are seen. While
the stakeholders
are theoretically
in favour of flood
management, their
participation is
still not ensured.
Operation of the
structures, maintenance
of drainage canal
and participation
of decision makers
has been missing.
River monitoring
is a necessity which
requires large sums
for hard material
and was neglected
until recently.
While river monitoring
on a regular basis
can reduce the severity
of erosion and,
thereby, the costs
of initial construction
and maintenance,
there is no systematic
measure being taken
for this.
Policy
and Reforms
Management
actions taken at
one location can
influence the geomorphology,
water quality and
ecosystem of other
areas, even far
beyond the project
area. Recent approaches
to river management
are multi-objective,
balancing beneficial
uses for agriculture,
fisheries, water
supply, navigation
with the protection
and enhancement
of the riverine
and flood plain
habitat and water
quality. These emerging
concepts make room
for the physical
processes to drive
the ecological restoration
by natural progression,
rather than engineering.
There
is a gradual shift
of the government
policies of the
early 1990s towards
a more comprehensive
and holistic approach
in water management
from expensive structural
measures for flood
control and drainage.
There is a new consensus
among stakeholders,
professionals and
the policy makers
on the need for
integrated water
resources management,
reflected in the
Bangladesh Water
and Flood Management
Strategy (FPCO,
1996).
The Flood Action
Plan culminated
in the publication
of the Bangladesh
Water and Flood
Management Strategy
(BWFMS)
in 1996. This recognised
the limitations
of earlier plans,
which had focused
too heavily on agricultural
development without
adequate consideration
of the needs of
other sectors. The
BWFMS recommended
that the government
should formulate
a National Water
Policy together
with a comprehensive
National Water Management
Plan (NWMP).
The government acted
promptly to implement
these recommendations.
The National Water
Policy (NWPo)
was prepared and
published in January
1999 following endorsement
of the National
Water Resources
Council (NWRC).
A new National Water
Management Plan
(NWMP)
was formulated and
approved in 2004.
The
National Water Policy
The
NWPO provides an
overall framework
for future management
of the water sector.
Directions are provided
on such issues as
overall basin-wide
planning, water
rights and allocation,
public and private
involvement, public
investment, water
supply and sanitation,
fisheries navigation,
agriculture industry
and environment.
The document is
intended to guide
both public and
private actions
to ensure optimal
development and
management of water
that benefits both
individuals and
society at large.
Other
related policies
In
1998, the National
Policy for Safe
Drinking Water Supply
and Sanitation (NPSWSS)
was published. The
main objective of
this policy is to
improve public health
and produce a safer
environment by reducing
water borne disease
and contamination
of surface and groundwater.
In this policy the
government recognised
the importance of
increasing participation
of users including
active support and
involvement of other
partners, such as
NGOs, market-oriented
business organisations
and similar private
organisations in
water and sanitation
development.
The
National Agricultural
Policy (NAP)
was issued in 1999.
The main goal of
this policy is to
maintain self-sufficiency
in food. It also
aims to ensure that
agriculture is profitable
to farmers by improved
input supply and
credit. One important
aspect of this policy
is that it sets
out clear agenda
to promote and develop
socially and environmentally-friendly
agriculture.
As early as 1994,
the National Forest
Policy (NFoP)
proposed approximately
20 per cent afforestation
by the year 2015.
For the first time
multiple uses of
the Sunderbans were
recognised including
water, forest and
fish. Issues such
as global warming,
desertification
and control of trade
of wild birds and
animals were also
addressed.
The
National Fisheries
Policy (NFiP)
of 1998 aims to
enhance fisheries
production and improve
socio-economic conditions
for households where
capture fishing
is the main activity;
to meet the demand
for animal protein;
to boost economic
growth by export
of fish and fisheries
product; and to
maintain ecological
balance. The policy
highlights the need
to conserve fish
habitats, to prevent
further drainage
of standing water
bodies for agricultural
development.
The
National Environmental
Policy (NEP)
of 1992 is broadly
similar to the National
Fisheries Policy.
This policy also
highlights the need
to maintain ecological
balance and overall
development through
protection and improvement
of the environment.
It seeks to identify
and regulate activities
that pollute and
degrade the environment
to ensure environmentally
sound development
in all sectors.
One important aspect
of this policy is
proposing to audit
existing flood control
and drainage projects
on an emergency
basis along with
steps to modify
these projects as
necessary.
Assessment
of policies
There
are no major contradictions
between national
policies for different
sectors with respect
to water resources
development in the
country. However,
there are no clear
guidelines in the
country as to how
the actions required
by different policies
should be coordinated.
Contradiction also
arises due to gaps
and interpretation
of policy issues.
A major gap in the
NPSWSS is its obscurity
in stating the need
for regulating private
sector activities
to ensure water
quality. Neither
the treatment levels
nor the industrial
effluents are discussed
in the policy. No
reference has been
made to the interaction
of wells for drinking
water and irrigation.
The NPSWSS
also does not clearly
address the coordination
of activities of
different agencies
in other sub-sectors.
The NAP
objective to maintain
food self-sufficiency
along with issues
related to water
requirement and
land use to meet
the policy objective
need to be adequately
addressed.
The NFiP
policy aims at expanding
the capture fisheries
resources with a
target to export
surplus. However,
this may trigger
conflict with the
agricultural sector
in the management
of water bodies.
Another area of
conflict is advocating
banning of discharge
of industrial wastes,
agro-chemicals and
fish-farm chemicals
into water bodies.
This may again give
rise to conflict
with the target
of NAP
to maintain food
self-sufficiency
by expanding HYV
crops. There are
no major conflicts
between NEP
and other policies
except for auditing
the FCD
projects. The NWPO
does not provide
any guidelines or
direction in this
regards.
Water
Development Issues:
Today and 2025
The
population projection
for 2025 for medium
fertility decline
is 181 million,
taking 1995 as the
base year, according
to National Water
Management Plan
(NWMP).
NWMP also predicts
that the urban population
will grow at a rate
of 8 per cent per
annum, which means
73 million inhabitants
in urban areas in
2025 compared to
27 million in 2000;
an increase of 2.7.
According to the
draft Development
Strategy formulated
by the National
Water Management
Plan Project (NWMPP),
under the medium
economic growth
scenario the GDP
will rise from 2021
billion in 1999-00
to 7965 billion
in 2024-25.
Considering medium
economic growth
and medium fertility
decline, it has
been estimated by
the NWMP
that an additional
demand of 9.5 million
tons of food grains
will be created
in 2025 compared
to 2000. Annual
fish consumption
will increase from
1.68 Mt/a to 4.43
Mt/a in 2025.
Increase in population
and economic activities
will be the main
driving force in
determining the
water demand in
the coming years.
Some indication
of the development
scenario could be
obtained from the
estimated land distribution
in 2025.
| Classification |
1995
(Mah) |
2025
(Mah) |
| River |
4626 |
4520 |
| Mangrove |
4957 |
5623 |
| Forest |
21058 |
24693 |
| Urban |
8697 |
12956 |
| Rural |
6734 |
8167 |
| Other |
3373 |
4383 |
| Water |
7584 |
10891 |
| Agriculture |
82784 |
68661 |
Changes
in the area of river,
forest, urban and
rural settlements
will not be appreciable.
However, the major
concern is the absolute
decline of approximately
1.4 Mha of agricultural
land. This is largely
due to the expansion
of fish production
on agricultural
lands. In that case,
the rate of increase
of yield should
be 2 per cent per
annum to maintain
food self-sufficiency.
In order to increase
production, most
of the irrigable
areas will need
to be brought under
irrigation. A 1997-98
estimate by NMIDP
shows that only
2.83 Mha out of
a potential 7.89
Mha is irrigated
in the Rabi (winter)
season. However,
it must be recognised
that getting water
to all irrigable
lands at an affordable
price will be difficult.
The above estimates
do not consider
the effect of global
warming. It is envisaged
that global warming
will have a major
impact on crop production
due to prolonged
dry season.
Flood
mitigation and management
Floodplains
of the major rivers
and their tributaries
and distributaries
cover around 80
per cent of Bangladesh.
As a result of very
flat topography
20 per cent of the
lands are inundated
due to spilling
of the rivers each
year during the
monsoon period (June-September).
Rainfall of high
intensity and long
duration in the
river catchments
causes drainage
congestion within
the country due
to inadequate conveyance
capacity of the
rivers. The situation
becomes severe when
peak flow in the
rivers synchronises
with high rainfall.
The nation experiences
around 37 per cent
inundation due to
floods every 10
years. In 1988 and
1998 more than 60
per cent land was
inundated.
During the last
50 years, hundreds
of kilometres of
embankments have
been constructed
by Bangladesh Water
Development Board
(BWDB),
Local Government
Engineering Department
(LGED)
and local authorities
(zilla parishad/union
parishads/pourashavas).
As time progresses
and more projects
are completed, interdependency
of these kinds of
flood mitigation
measures with the
surrounding water
environment has
resulted in a number
of adverse impacts.
Some of the adverse
impacts include
increase in the
depth, duration
and extent of inundation
in the unprotected
areas, increase
in sedimentation
rate in the drainage
channels, increase
in flood levels,
drainage congestion
in the protected
areas, loss of fish
habitats and breeding
grounds. Due to
inadequate maintenance
of flood embankment,
embankment breaches
are common phenomenon.
These embankment
breaches are the
cause of major flood
disaster particularly
in the areas on
the right bank of
Jamuna River. Therefore,
mitigation measure
for one hazard can
cause a wide range
of hazards in other
areas.
Human
intervention and
associated impacts
Human
intervention in
the flood plains
and in the water
bodies has introduced
large scale environmental,
social and economic
impacts. Conventional
methods of engineering
practices of analysis
and design had to
use simplified approaches
without considering
interactive responses
from system interventions,
which is inevitable
in the complex river
and flood plain
system in Bangladesh.
The designers had
to opt for conservative
design parameters
to remain on the
safe side, or to
omit some very important
issues which later
proved to be the
main reasons behind
unacceptable hazards
that took place
within and around
project area.
Freshwater
withdrawal and salinity
intrusion
Salinity
in the coastal areas,
particularly in
the south-west region
is a major concern.
Salinity intrusion
in the south-west
has increased due
to low fresh water
flow through Gorai
during dry season.
The main reason
is the withdrawal
of water in the
upstream resulting
in degradation of
the Gorai offtake.
This has resulted
in major adverse
impacts on the environment
and socio-economic
condition in the
area. The historic
Ganges Water Sharing
Treaty (GWT)
with India signed
in 1996 makes a
certain quantum
of flow available
to Bangladesh during
the dry season.
The main challenge
in the future will
be to best utilise
this additional
flow to restore
the Gorai and other
rivers; arrest environmental
degradation by salinity
control; extend
irrigation facilities;
control of sedimentation.
Diversion, distribution
and management of
this additional
flow will require
major interventions
like a barrage on
the Ganges, water
control structures
and distribution
canal in the Ganges
Dependent Areas
(GDA).
A detailed study
on the feasibility
of various intervention
options should immediately
be undertaken.
Sedimentation
of rivers, estuaries
and coasts
Each
year a huge volume
of sediment is being
conveyed by the
major rivers to
the sea. Although
it is difficult
to quantify the
volume of sediment
accurately, estimates
by different studies
show that the quantity
of sediment ranges
somewhere between
0.5 to 2 billion
tonnes per year.
It is, however,
reasonable to state
that sediment load
could be in excess
of 1 billion tonnes
per year. This is
a potential resource,
which needs to be
harnessed in the
reclamation of land
in the coastal areas.
An NWMPP
estimate suggests
that if 10 per cent
of the sediment
is deposited on
31,000 km2
land with flooding
deeper than 0.9m
with a consolidation
of 1.5t/m, then
the thickness of
the deposit would
average 10mm per
year. This is important
for compensation
of land subsidence
which is typically
2mm per year.
Erosion
of river banks
The
seasonal variation
of river flows causes
variation in sediment
transport and as
a result, erosion
of river banks occurs.
The possible after
effects are migration
of bank lines, resulting
in a loss of valuable
lands. Previous
studies have estimated
that by the year
2025 around 3,575
km2 area
in the erodible
river valleys of
Brahmaputra, Ganges,
Padma, Lower Meghna
and estuary will
be lost due to erosion.
On the other hand,
3,665 km2
land will be gained
due to accretion
in the same period.
From these figures
it may seem that
the loss is not
very significant.
But this has major
social, economic
and environmental
implications. Structural
measures like river
bank protection,
canalisation etc.
for mitigation for
erosion in the extremely
dynamic river valleys
of Jamuna, Padma,
Ganges or Lower
Meghna would require
huge investment
in implementation
and more so in maintenance.
Planning of any
such mitigation
measure requires
prediction of river
erosion and the
most suitable measure
for mitigation based
on their resulting
impact upstream
and downstream of
the mitigation work.
Remote sensing data
can be used for
study of pattern
of changes to river
plan form and bank
lines. Mathematical
models could be
useful to predict
river erosion, and
study of different
mitigation options
and their impacts.
Prediction of erosion
for early warning
can also save life
and property.
Cyclone
and storm surge
Bangladesh
has over 700 km
of coastline, which
is exposed to recurring
cyclones from the
Bay of Bengal. The
coastal areas have
experienced over
42 major cyclones
in the last 125
years. These cyclones
cause immense damage
to the coastal social
and economic life
and to the environment.
In 1991, the coastal
areas experienced
a storm with a surge
height of 4.0-5.0
m, killing 140,000
of the population
and damaging livestock,
crops, property
and infrastructure
in the area. Since
the 1960s a large
number of polders
have been constructed
in the tidal plains
of the south as
mitigation measures
against tidal surges
and saline water
intrusion. A large
number of cyclone
shelters have also
been constructed
to save life in
the event of a storm
surge.
One
of the major mitigation
measures are land-use
policies, which
should guide development
activities in disaster
prone areas. The
land-use policy
should be based
on analysis of risk
due to hazard. Deterministic
models can be used
to simulate any
events and GIS could
be very a handy
tool for risk mapping
based on risk analysis
on the basis of
an inventory of
the property at
risk to the hazard,
and estimates of
different intensities
of hazard events.
Probabilistic models
could be used to
take into account
of the whole range
of likely events
by assigning probabilities
to each range of
events and estimating
the damage that
would be expected
to occur as a result.
Water
stress
Agricultural drought
is a common phenomenon
in many areas of
Bangladesh in post
monsoon and dry
season. In major
cities, scarcity
of water for drinking
and sanitation is
a major problem.
Main causes of drought
are limited rainfall,
high temperature
associated with
low humidity and
withdrawal of water
in the upstream.
Over withdrawal
of groundwater is
causing lowering
of groundwater in
many areas; as a
result, many Shallow
Tubewells (STW)
are becoming inoperable.
Moreover, low flow
in rivers in the
dry period and lowering
of groundwater table
is causing environmental
problems like salinity
intrusion in surface
and groundwater,
increase in the
concentration of
pollution in surface
water, sedimentation
etc. The problem
becomes multifaceted
when there is scarcity
of ground water
during the monsoon
in most years, especially
in the flood-controlled
area. This reveals
the significance
of annual flood
plain's inundation
for ground water
recharge.
Urban
water supply and
sanitation
Pollution from human
and industrial sources
is the main water
quality problem
in the river systems
near urban areas.
Buriganga in Dhaka
and Karnafuli in
Chittagong are the
worst affected.
Other rivers are
also showing gradual
decline in water
quality. It has
been estimated that
urban population
will increase by
2.7 times by 2025.
The gross daily
water demand in
the major metropolitan
cities (Dhaka, Chittagong,
Khulna and Rajshahi)
will rise from the
present 2460 Ml/d
(million litres
per day) to 7970
Ml/d assuming a
system loss of 20
per cent. There
is already a major
shortage of required
supply of safe water.
Due to over abstraction
and loss of recharge
areas, the groundwater
table in Dhaka has
declined at an alarming
rate over the last
couple of decades.
A 1997 study by
Institute of Water
Modelling (IWM)
has shown that the
maximum drawdown
due to groundwater
abstraction was
25m. However, this
drawdown could have
been reduced to
15m by conjunctive
use of surface and
groundwater. Based
on model study,
the IWM
recommended the
use of surface water
during wet season
from the rivers
surrounding Dhaka
and use of groundwater
during dry period.
It may be mentioned
here that cost of
treatment of surface
water will be lower
in wet season because
of lower pollution
level. Recharge
during wet season
will raise the groundwater
table, which will
reduce the cost
of groundwater abstraction
during dry season.
Alternative sources
like River Jamna,
which is only 80km
away with reliable
flow needs to be
investigated. Conjunctive
use in other major
cities and urban
areas should also
be studied. Other
options relate to
more stringent regulations
implemented on the
ground relating
to protection of
the quality of water
and reduction of
wastage and unaccounted-for
water. Community
participation in
the process is vital.
Demand management
by imposing tariffs
could be useful
to discourage wastage
of water. Private
sector management
of water supply
system could be
more efficient in
the management of
demand and quality
services.
Dhaka
has the largest
piped sewerage system
in Bangladesh; however,
the existing system
serves only 20 per
cent of the city.
Of this only 3 per
cent reaches the
DWASA
sewage treatment
plant at Pagla,
the rest leaks into
ground or surface
water system, which
cause widespread
pollution. 40 per
cent households
in Dhaka have septic
tanks with soak
wells. In the future,
with the increase
in population density,
the quantities will
not only exceed
soak well capacity,
but high land values
will discourage
the setting aside
of land for such
purposes. Therefore,
immediate measures
to collect and carry
the effluent for
treatment and disposal
are necessary.
Arsenic
contamination of
groundwater
The
issue of arsenic
is now the most
important environmental
concern of Bangladesh.
In recent times
arsenic in tube-well
waters has upset
the drinking water
supply from groundwater.
Arsenic has turned
into a national
health issue, groundwater
users panicking
as a result. Out
of 64 districts,
arsenic contamination
in groundwater has
been detected in
59 districts. The
most common mitigation
measure being taken
is identifying the
tube-wells with
arsenic level crossing
allowable limits
for drinking water.
Various agencies
are working all
over Bangladesh
in testing tube-well
water for arsenic.
The testing methods
have not yet been
standardised, field
activities are not
coordinated, valuable
information from
field investigations
is not properly
archived for further
use. There is an
urgent need to develop
an arsenic database,
which should include
information on the
tube-wells being
affected, the population
under threat, mitigation
|